· Square Cafe project, In the news

Buffington Updates Rotary on Downtown Projects

Speaking to the Lewistown Rotary, Mike Buffington shared updates on 19 and 21 South Brown Street and explained the Square Cafe project at 13 and 15 East Market Street.

19 South Brown Street

Mike Buffington, president of MAB Holdings, gave the Lewistown Rotary an update on downtown projects in October 2026.

19 South Brown Street is the most recently completed major renovation. Vacant for years, it now has commercial space downstairs and apartments upstairs. Many residents are nurses and doctors connected to the nearby Geisinger School of Nursing, and being steps from the Square is a big draw.

Next door, 21 South Brown Street was acquired with recent facade improvements already in place, and its offices are being remodeled as new tenants move in.

The current project is moving The Square Cafe & Bakery into the former Wilson’s Gift and Jewelry building at 13 East Market Street. Beside it, the former Trolley Car Cafe at 15 East Market Street was a prefabricated structure never meant to be permanent and couldn’t be saved, so a new kitchen building is going up in its place. Buffington said he prefers to preserve as much history as possible in his renovations and never wants to demolish a piece of history, but that wasn’t feasible here.

Follow the Square Cafe project.

Photos

  • 21 South Brown Street
    21 South Brown Street

More news

All news →

Schedule a Tour

Tell us what kind of space you need, or ask about a specific property. Give us a call at 717-248-4997 or fill out the form, and we'll get back to you within one business day.

Office

Buffington Property Management
101 East Market Street
Lewistown, PA 17044

Get directions to our office →