· Square Cafe project, History
On the Corner, On the Square: The Fosnot-Wilson Building Story
Jeremy Landes of WCHX 105.5 FM's The Valley Vault traced more than 200 years at 13 East Market Street, from Samuel Edmiston's 1790s home to Wilson's Gifts and Jewelry and the new Square Cafe & Bakery.

Shared with permission from Jeremy Landes, host of The Valley Vault on WCHX 105.5 FM. Originally posted on Facebook on November 20, 2026.
The Valley Vault is a popular local history segment on the CHiX Morning FiX show, shining a spotlight on the heritage, forgotten landmarks, historic businesses and folklore of Mifflin and Juniata counties.
For generations of people who shopped in downtown Lewistown, Wilson’s Gifts and Jewelry was one of those businesses that almost everybody recognized. Located at 13 East Market Street, directly on Monument Square, the store was known for its jewelry, gifts, watches, and other merchandise. But perhaps just as memorable was its longtime advertising slogan, “On the Corner, On the Square.”
What many people may not realize is that the history of this particular corner stretches back to the earliest days of Lewistown. Long before Wilson’s moved into the building in 1971, the property had been home to some of the community’s earliest residents, businesses, and public officials. And today, the same building is preparing for another chapter in its history.
Much of the information in today’s Valley Vault comes from extensive research conducted by Forest K. Fisher of the Mifflin County Historical Society. His October 2009 article, “On the Corner – On the Square,” traces the property’s history through more than 200 years of deeds, newspaper advertisements, tax records, and ownership changes. The research also acknowledges the contributions of former Mifflin County Historical Society research librarian Jean Laughlin.
The story begins in the late 1700s, when Lewistown was still a developing community. The property that would eventually become 11–13 East Market Street was part of land originally associated with Dorcas Holt Buchanan. In 1791, Samuel Edmiston acquired the larger tract of land that included the future town site.
Edmiston was an important figure in the early history of Mifflin County. When the county was established in 1789, he was appointed its first prothonotary, a position responsible for maintaining important court records and other legal documents.
Edmiston also helped lay out the streets and lots of Lewistown. Working with James Potter, he helped establish the basic layout of the new county seat. One of those original properties, identified as Lot 76, would eventually become the familiar corner occupied by Wilson’s.
By October 1798, Edmiston had constructed a 2-story brick residence on the property. Historical records indicate that he conducted the official business of the prothonotary’s office from his home. That means the location wasn’t simply an early residence. It also played a role in the county’s earliest government operations.
Edmiston died in 1804, and the property remained associated with his family until it passed into other hands several years later.
In 1812, the property was purchased by James Milliken, a businessman originally from Kishacoquillas Valley. Milliken operated a mercantile business dealing in dry goods, groceries, and grain. He eventually became involved in banking, milling, transportation, and other enterprises that helped shape the region’s early economy.
By 1814, the western portion of the property, including the brick residence, had been sold to William P. Maclay. The Maclay family continued owning the corner for decades. Eventually, the building was adapted for commercial use, reflecting the growing importance of downtown Lewistown as a shopping and business center.
Beginning in the 1840s, Frederick J. Hoffman operated a store at the location, selling groceries, hardware, drugs, and other merchandise. Historical newspaper advertisements confirm that his business was operating there by November 1843 and continued until his retirement in 1870.
Then came another name that became an important part of the corner’s history.
In 1870, the property was purchased by John Beale Selheimer, a prominent Lewistown businessman and Civil War veteran.
Selheimer had a particularly interesting background. He had been chosen as captain of the Logan Guards in 1858 and commanded the unit when it departed Lewistown on April 16, 1861, answering President Abraham Lincoln’s call for volunteers at the beginning of the Civil War.
Following his military service, Selheimer continued expanding his business interests. In 1871, he established his hardware operation on the corner of Monument Square.
The store sold an extensive assortment of merchandise, including tools, cutlery, stoves, agricultural equipment, paints, oils, glass, wallpaper, and household supplies. It also provided hardware used by local industries, including furnaces, mills, and other manufacturing businesses.
Historical newspaper accounts described Selheimer’s newly renovated store as one of the finest business establishments in the area. For decades, the hardware business became a fixture of downtown Lewistown.
After John Selheimer died in 1893, his son Joseph continued operating the store. The family remained associated with the property until 1916, when Joseph retired and sold the business and building to Walter Fosnot.
That sale led to one of the biggest changes in the corner’s history.
Walter Fosnot was another prominent figure in Lewistown. He was involved in the newspaper business, eventually serving as president and general manager of the Sentinel Printing Company. Interestingly, he also served as president of the Lewistown Broadcasting Company, making him part of our community’s early radio history.
Fosnot purchased the property in 1916 and arranged for the aging brick building to be demolished. The local construction company W. D. Steinbach Sons was hired to construct a new commercial building on the same site.
The new 3-story structure was completed in 1917, and that is the building that remains on the corner today.
According to a December 1917 article in The Sentinel, the new building measured approximately 30 feet across its frontage and extended 140 feet back from the street. It was considered one of Lewistown’s most modern commercial buildings at the time.
The first floor became home to Mifflin County Hardware Company, while the upper floors contained offices and apartments. A historical publication from 1925 praised the building’s design and the amount of space it provided for displaying and selling merchandise.
Over the following decades, the building became home to several familiar businesses.
Mifflin County Hardware operated there until approximately 1929. Specker’s Furniture followed in 1930, bringing a different kind of merchandise to the former hardware location.
Then, in 1944, Bob Davis Clothing Store moved into the building. Robert D. Davis was already an experienced retailer, having worked in clothing stores in other Pennsylvania communities before establishing his own business in Lewistown.
The Bob Davis Store specialized in men’s and boys’ clothing and accessories. It remained on Monument Square until 1970, serving customers for approximately 26 years.
But here’s something else you may not have known about the building.
According to Forest Fisher’s research, the basement was home to various billiard and pool halls for approximately 50 years. Historical street directories identify several operators during that period, including William and Ralph Harmon, Clarence Bowsman, Carl King, Malcolm Miller, and G. Charles Ernest.
Abbey’s Pool Hall, operated by Albert Watson, was also listed in the building in 1972.
Meanwhile, the upper floors housed a variety of other businesses and professional offices. Over the years, tenants included dentists, physicians, insurance businesses, and government-related offices. Apartments also occupied portions of the upper floors.
That means the building was much more than a single storefront. It was a place where people shopped, worked, conducted business, and sometimes lived.
But for many people reading this, the most familiar chapter began in the early 1970s.
Paul F. Wilson Sr. had entered the jewelry business in 1965. He acquired Weaver Gift and Jewelry, which had been operated by Edwin and Evelyn Weaver at 23 East Market Street.
Paul Wilson had followed several different career paths before entering the jewelry business. Born in Blandburg, Blair County, in 1919, he came to Lewistown during his younger years. His father had operated a meat market on Valley Street, and Paul later worked in pharmaceutical sales, sand and gravel operations, and the fertilizer industry.
In January 1970, Wilson purchased the Fosnot building from Walter Fosnot’s heirs. The following year, he moved his gift and jewelry business into the prominent corner location.
The grand opening took place in September 1971, and The Sentinel carried an advertisement inviting customers to visit the new store.
To celebrate the opening, Wilson’s offered several prizes, including a half-carat diamond ring, a Bulova watch, a Fostoria vase, a Fenton collectible, a clock, and other gifts.
The September 14, 1971 edition of The Sentinel announced the winners. The diamond was awarded to Mrs. K. D. Swartzell of Lewistown, while Connie Goss of Reedsville won the watch. Other winners included Grace Rager of Lewistown, Paul R. Fogelman, Elaine Zellers, and Julia Moore of Burnham.
It’s an interesting little detail that gives us a glimpse of how local businesses promoted grand openings during that era.
The store quickly became associated with its familiar location and the slogan “On the Corner, On the Square.”
Over the years, generations of customers visited Wilson’s to purchase jewelry, watches, gifts, and other items for birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, weddings, and special occasions.
For some people, it may have been the place where they purchased an engagement ring or a special gift. For others, it was simply one of the stores they remembered visiting while shopping downtown.
When Paul Wilson Sr. retired in 1980, his son, Paul F. Wilson Jr., succeeded him in operating the business.
In 1986, Paul Jr. and his wife, Vicki, acquired the property from his father, continuing the family’s involvement with the store and the historic building.
Wilson’s remained a familiar business on Monument Square for decades, becoming one of the names closely associated with downtown Lewistown.
The building also gained another connection with local history through an artistic project that many residents will remember.
In 2013, Juniata County artist Dwight Kirkland created a mural celebrating Lewistown’s historic movie theaters on the side of the Wilson’s building. The artwork featured the Embassy, Miller, Rialto, Temple, and Pastime theaters, along with images and references to people who were part of the community’s movie history.
Kirkland donated his work to the community, and the mural became another reminder of the many stories connected with downtown Lewistown.
Wilson’s Gifts and Jewelry continued operating at 13 East Market Street until 2016, ending a 45-year chapter at that corner.
But jewelry and gift sales didn’t immediately disappear from the building.
In 2016, KC’s Gifts, Jewelry & Awards began operating there, continuing the property’s retail tradition. That business remained at the location until 2023.
The next chapter came with Lost Art Studio and Vintage, which occupied the building during 2024 and 2025.
By then, plans were developing for another major transformation of the historic property.
During 2026, renovations began preparing the former Wilson’s building for a new purpose. The work has included restoring architectural features that had been hidden or altered during decades of commercial changes.
Among the discoveries were original leaded glass windows and oak woodwork dating to the building’s earlier years. Contractors have worked to uncover, clean, and restore those features while updating the space for its next tenant.
And the next chapter is one that connects directly with another location we’ve recently explored in Valley Vault.
The Square Cafe & Bakery, currently located at 10 West Market Street, announced plans in July 2026 to move to the former Wilson’s property at 13 East Market Street.
The project includes restoring the existing building to provide indoor dining overlooking Monument Square. A new kitchen, bakery, and outdoor patio are being constructed on the neighboring property at 15 East Market Street, formerly home to the Trolley Car Cafe.
That neighboring property has its own fascinating history, dating back to the Club Diner that arrived in 1928, something we recently covered in Valley Vault.
By combining the 2 properties, the redevelopment project will create a new restaurant space while preserving important architectural features of the original Fosnot-Wilson Building.
According to an October 28, 2026 report published by The Lewistown Sentinel, much of the renovation work inside the former Wilson’s building was already completed, with crews working on the new kitchen and patio next door.
The Square Cafe & Bakery is expected to open at its new location in early 2027.
And that brings us to the latest chapter of a property whose history stretches back to Lewistown’s earliest years.
Think about everything this corner has witnessed.
It began as the home and office of one of Mifflin County’s first officials. It became associated with merchants who helped supply a growing community, including a Civil War veteran whose hardware store served generations of local residents.
The original building was replaced in 1917, and the new structure went on to house hardware, furniture, clothing, gifts, jewelry, professional offices, apartments, and even pool halls.
For 45 years, Wilson’s Gifts and Jewelry gave the building one of its most recognizable identities.
And now, as the property approaches another chapter in its history, the familiar corner is being prepared to welcome customers once again, this time as a restaurant.
I think one of the most interesting things about local history is how buildings can change while remaining part of the community’s everyday life.
The businesses may come and go, and the signs above the doors may change, but the memories connected with those places remain.
For many longtime residents, that corner will probably always be remembered as Wilson’s.
And I’m sure some people still think of it as the Bob Davis Store, Specker’s Furniture, or even one of the older businesses that occupied the property before Wilson’s arrived.
Now I’d love to hear from you!
What are your memories of Wilson’s Gifts and Jewelry? Did you purchase an engagement ring, a wedding gift, a watch, or something special for a loved one? Do you remember Paul Wilson Sr., Paul Jr., Vicki, or any of the employees who worked there?
I’m also interested in hearing from anyone who remembers the businesses that occupied the building before Wilson’s. Did you shop at Bob Davis Clothing Store or Specker’s Furniture? Does anyone remember the pool hall in the basement or the offices upstairs?
If you have old photographs of Wilson’s, advertisements, receipts, jewelry boxes, shopping bags, or pictures of the building during its earlier years, please share them in the comments.
Share your memories on Jeremy’s Facebook post →
I also want to recognize Forest K. Fisher and the Mifflin County Historical Society for the extensive research that helped preserve this property’s history. Research like this is what makes it possible to bring these stories back to life for people who may never have heard them before.
More than 2 centuries have passed since Samuel Edmiston built his home on that corner. The original structure is long gone, but the building that replaced it in 1917 remains one of downtown Lewistown’s recognizable landmarks.
And while the names have changed over the generations, one familiar phrase still seems like the perfect way to remember this part of our community.
“On the Corner, On the Square.”
Read Jeremy Landes’s original post on Facebook · Read Forest K. Fisher’s full history of the corner · See the Trolley Car’s history at 15 East Market Street · Follow the Square Cafe project


